Scores by leading wine critics
Last updated: December 8th, 2024
| AZ. AGR. FRANK CORNELISSEN, Etna-Sicily | |||||
| GUIDE | CRITIC | WINE | VINTAGE | TYPE | SCORES |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | Magma® | 2017 | Rosso | 99 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | Magma® | 2014 | Rosso | 99 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | Magma® | 2016 | Rosso | 97 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | Magma® | 2013 | Rosso | 97 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® VA | 2017 | Rosso | 96 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® CS | 2013 | Rosso | 96 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® CR | 2017 | Rosso | 95 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® PA | 2017 | Rosso | 95 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® CR | 2016 | Rosso | 95 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® PA | 2014 | Rosso | 95 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® VA | 2013 | Rosso | 95 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® CS | 2016 | Rosso | 94 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® CS | 2014 | Rosso | 94 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® MC | 2013 | Rosso | 94 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® PA | 2016 | Rosso | 93 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® FM | 2014 | Rosso | 93 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® Classico | 2016 | Rosso | 92 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® Classico | 2013 | Rosso | 92 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® FM | 2016 | Rosso | 91 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | MunJebel® Classico | 2015 | Rosso | 91 |
| IWR | J.d'Angelo | Contadino | 2013 | Rosso | 90 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | Magma® | 2020 | Rosso | 94 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® MC | 2020 | Rosso | 94 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | Magma® | 2017 | Rosso | 93+ |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® VA | 2020 | Rosso | 93 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® FM | 2020 | Rosso | 93 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® VA | 2017 | Rosso | 93 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | Magma® | 2016 | Rosso | 93 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | Magma® | 2014 | Rosso | 93 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® FM | 2016 | Rosso | 92 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® CR | 2020 | Rosso | 92 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® CD | 2020 | Rosso | 92 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® Classico | 2017 | Rosso | 91+ |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® CR | 2017 | Rosso | 91 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® VA | 2016 | Rosso | 91 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | Magma® | 2013 | Rosso | 91 |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® MC | 2014 | Rosso | 90+ |
| The Wine Advocate | M.Larner | MunJebel® PA | 2017 | Rosso | 90 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | Magma® | 2019 | Rosso | 97+ |
| Vinous | E.Guido | Magma® | 2017 | Rosso | 96+ |
| Vinous | E.Guido | Magma® | 2020 | Rosso | 96 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® PA | 2020 | Rosso | 95 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® VA | 2020 | Rosso | 95 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® FM | 2019 | Rosso | 95 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | Magma® | 2015 | Rosso | 95 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® FM | 2020 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® CR | 2020 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® CD | 2020 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® CS | 2020 | Rosso | 93 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® MC | 2019 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® FM | 2017 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | MunJebel® CS | 2017 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | MunJebel® VA | 2015 | Rosso | 94 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® CR | 2019 | Rosso | 93+ |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® Classico | 2020 | Rosso | 93 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® Bianco VA | 2020 | Bianco | 93 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® Classico | 2020 | Rosso | 93 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | MunJebel® VA | 2017 | Rosso | 93 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | MunJebel® CS | 2015 | Rosso | 93 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® MC | 2020 | Rosso | 92 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® VA | 2019 | Rosso | 92 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® Classico | 2019 | Rosso | 92 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® Classico | 2022 | Rosso | 92 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | MunJebel® Classico | 2022 | Bianco | 92 |
| Vinous | E.Guido | Susucaru® Rosso | 2019 | Rosso | 91 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | Munjebel® Classico | 2017 | Bianco | 91 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | Munjebel® FM | 2015 | Rosso | 91 |
| Vinous | I.d'Agata | Munjebel® Classico | 2014 | Rosso | 91 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Magma® | 2021 | Rosso | 100 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® VA | 2021 | Rosso | 98 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® CR | 2021 | Rosso | 97 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® FM | 2021 | Rosso | 96 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Bianco VA | 2021 | Bianco | 95 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® MC | 2021 | Rosso | 95 |
| K.O'Keefe | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® PA | 2021 | Rosso | 94 |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Magma® | 2020 | Rosso | 19.5 |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Magma® | 2021 | Rosso | 19+ |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® CS | 2021 | Rosso | 18,5+ |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® VA | 2021 | Rosso | 18.5 |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® MC | 2021 | Rosso | 18+ |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® PA | 2021 | Rosso | 18+ |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® FM | 2021 | Rosso | 18+ |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® CR | 2021 | Rosso | 18 |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® Classico | 2022 | Bianco | 17.5 |
| WeinWisser | Giuseppe Lauria | Munjebel® Classico | 2022 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| Vinum Magazin | Christian Eder | Magma® | 2021 | Rosso | 19 |
| Vinum Magazin | Christian Eder | Magma® | 2017 | Rosso | 19 |
| Vinum Magazin | Christian Eder | Munjebel® FM | 2014 | Rosso | 18 |
| Vinum Magazin | Christian Eder | Magma® | 2012 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® VA | 2016 | Rosso | 97 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Classico | 2017 | Rosso | 97 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Susucaru® Rosso | 2017 | Rosso | 94 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Magma® | 10/2012 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® CS | 9/2012 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Magma® | 2016 | Rosso | 92 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Classico | 2017 | Bianco | 92 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Classico | 9/2012 | Bianco | 92 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Magma® | 5R/2006 | Rosso | 92 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® VA | 8/2011 | Rosso | 91 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® VA | 7/2010 | Rosso | 91 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Classico | 6/2009+2010 | Rosso | 91 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Magma® | 6/2007 | Rosso | 91 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® MC | 9/2012 | Rosso | 90 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® MC | 8/2011 | Rosso | 90 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® BB/10th Anniversary | 7/2010 | Rosso | 90 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Classico | 4/2006+2007 | Rosso | 90 |
| Wine Enthusiast | K.O'Keefe | Munjebel® Classico | 5/2007+2008 | Rosso | 90 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 8/2009 | Rosso | 96 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 7/2008 | Rosso | 96 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel® PA | 2016 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 2016 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Contadino 4 | 2006 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 1/2001 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 5R/2006 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Contadino 7 | 2009 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel® VA | 7/2010 | Rosso | 95 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel® Classico | 2016 | Bianco | 94 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel CR | 2016 | Rosso | 94 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel VA | 2016 | Rosso | 94 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel® Classico | 3/2006 | Bianco | 94 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Bianco MunJebel VA 6 | 2009 | Bianco | 94 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel CS | 2016 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel FM | 2016 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | MunJebel 3 | 2006 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | MunJebel 4 | 2006/7 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Mongibello 1 | 2001/2 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | MunJebel 7 | 2009/10 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | MunJebel 7 10th Anniversary (BB) | 2010 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 4VA/2004 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 6/2007 | Rosso | 93 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel MC | 2016 | Rosso | 92 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel® Classico | 4/2007 | Bianco | 92 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Contadino | 8/2010 | Rosso | 92 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Magma® | 4VB/2004 | Rosso | 92 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Contadino | 5/2007 | Rosso | 91 |
| Wineanorak.com | J.Goode | Munjebel® Classico | 7/2010 | Bianco | 90 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Magma® | 8/2009 | Rosso | 96 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel®Classico | 7/2010 | Rosso | 94 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel® Classico | 6/2009 | Rosso | 94 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Magma® | 7/2008 | Rosso | 93 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Contadino | Apr-06 | Rosso | 93 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel® VA | 7VA/2010 | Rosso | 93 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Magma® | 4VB/2004 | Rosso | 92 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Contadino | 7/2009 | Rosso | 92 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel® | 4/2007 | Rosso | 92 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel® Classico | 7/2010 | Bianco | 91 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel® Classico | 4/2007 | Bianco | 91 |
| wine-pages.com | T.Cannavan | Munjebel® Classico | 6VA/2009 | Bianco | 90 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® Classico | 2014 | Bianco | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® Classico | 2019 | Bianco | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® Classico | 9/2012 | Bianco | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Contadino | 2014 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Contadino | 2014 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Contadino | 2017 | Rosso | 16 + |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Contadino | 2014 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Robinson MW | Contadino | 4/2006 | Rosso | 16 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Contadino | 8/2010 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Magma® | 2013 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Magma® | 2014 | Rosso | 17++ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Magma® | 2017 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Magma® | 2013 | Rosso | 17++ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Magma® | 2014 | Rosso | 17++ |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Robinson MW | Magma® | 6/2007 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Magma® | 9/2011 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® Classico | 2014 | Rosso | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® Classico | 2014 | Rosso | 16 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® Classico | 2015 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® Classico | 2017 | Rosso | 16+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | R.Hemming MW | Munjebel® Classico | 2018 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® Classico | 2019 | Rosso | 16.5++ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® Classico | 2013 | Rosso | 16 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® Classico | 2014 | Rosso | 16.5+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Robinson MW | Munjebel® Classico | 3/2005 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® Classico | 8/2010+2011 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® CA | 2017 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® CR | 2017 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® CS | 2017 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® CS | 2013 | Rosso | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® CS | 2014 | Rosso | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® CS | 9/2012 | Rosso | 18 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® FM | 2017 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® MC | 2017 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® MC | 2013 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® MC | 2014 | Rosso | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® MC | 8/2011 | Rosso | 17.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® PA | 2017 | Rosso | 16.5+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® PA | 2014 | Rosso | 16 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® VA | 2013 | Rosso | 15.5 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® VA | 2014 | Rosso | 17++ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® VA | 2017 | Rosso | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® VA | 2013 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Munjebel® VA | 2014 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Munjebel® VA | 8/2011 | Rosso | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Robinson MW | Susucaru® Rosato | 2007 | Rosato | 17 |
| JancisRobinson.com | W.Speller | Susucaru® Rosato | 2015 | Rosato | 17+ |
| JancisRobinson.com | J.Harding MW | Susucaru® Rosso | 2019 | Rosso | 16.5 |
| Decanter | Aldo Fiordelli | Magma® | 2017 | Rosso | 96 |
| Decanter | Aldo Fiordelli | Munjebel® VA | 2017 | Rosso | 96 |
| Espresso Guida Vini | Luca Gardini | Magma® | 2020 | Rosso | 98+ |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | Magma® | 2021 | Rosso | 98 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | Magma® | 2020 | Rosso | 97 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | MunJebel® SC | 2021 | Rosso | 97 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | MunJebel® Classico | 2020 | Rosso | 97 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | MunJebel® MC | 2020 | Rosso | 96 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | MunJebel® CD | 2020 | Rosso | 96 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | MunJebel® FM | 2020 | Rosso | 95 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | Munjebel® CS | 2020 | Rosso | 95 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | Munjebel® CR | 2020 | Rosso | 95 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | Munjebel® Perpetuum 2 | NV | Rosso | 95 |
| Jamessuckling.com | James Suckling | Munjebel® Classico | 2020 | Bianco | 94 |
| Gambero Rosso Guide | Magma® | 2020 | Rosso | 3 Bicchieri | |
| Gambero Rosso Guide | Munjebel® MC (Vigneto Colla) | 2021 | Rosso | 3 Bicchieri | |
| Gambero Rosso Guide | Munjebel® Bianco VA | 2020 | Bianco | 2 Bicchieri | |
| Le Paradis du Vin | Hao Shen | Munjebel® FM | 2018 | Rosso | 95 |
| Le Paradis du Vin | Hao Shen | Munjebel® CD | 2018 | Rosso | 95 |
| Le Paradis du Vin | Hao Shen | Munjebel® Perpetuum 1 | NV | Rosso | 93 |
| Le Paradis du Vin | Hao Shen | Munjebel® CR | 2018 | Rosso | 92 |
| Le Paradis du Vin | Hao Shen | Munjebel® Classico | 2019 | Bianco | 91 |
| Le Paradis du Vin | Hao Shen | Munjebel® Classico | 2020 | Rosso | 91 |